Like most Meg Ryan comedies,
''Uptown Girls'' has a heroine who's adorable only because it says so in the
script.
Molly (Brittany Murphy) is a 22-year-old Manhattan
party girl living off the inheritance she received after her mother and rock
star father died in a plane crash when she was 8.
When her accountant bails with her golden nest egg,
Molly must find a job and quell her extravagance. It doesn't help that she lacks
a practical bone in her body.
She's propped up by the inevitable selfless friends (Marley
Shelton, Donald Faison) in such films and gets an unlikely job. Molly will be
nanny to Ray (Dakota Fanning), a bratty, neurotic 8-year-old whose dad lies in a
coma and whose music exec mom (Heather Locklear) hardly knows her.
It's hate at first sight for neatnik Ray and messy
Molly. But the film quickly turns to predictable consciousness-raising and
sentimental sisterliness. Molly must learn to become a responsible adult, while
Ray must lighten up and enjoy being a kid.
All this would work better if Molly truly were lovable.
Though Murphy is radiant, and her laugh is infectious, her free-spiritedness is
thrust in our face like a pointy object in a 3-D movie.
She's reckless and exasperating and deserving of each
setback she gets.
Directed by Boaz Yakin (''Remember the Titans''),
''Girls'' is clumsily photographed, and its score is witlessly perky. In tone it
lurches from nutty slapstick to soulful morbidity, and a halfhearted romance
between Molly and a musician (Jesse Spencer) is a subplot played up in the ads
to draw the date crowd.
Loose ends are left dangling, and the paused
exclamation, ''Oh . . . my . . . God'' is repeated enough times to qualify as a
mantra.
Fanning was a bright child star in the tender ''I Am
Sam,'' but here she is squandered, playing one-note disdain for so long that her
turnabout is unconvincing. Actors should progress along character arcs, not
teleport to the other end.
By default, the film's most endearing character is
Molly's pet pig, Moo. When Molly finds the runty oinker forlornly stranded in a
hall after she's evicted from her apartment, he gets the movie's most deserved
heart tugs. Those bestowed on Molly and Ray are just a ritual of playing by the
book